Aunt Cheryl’s Old-Fashioned Baked Mac and Cheese for a Crowd

Recipes are more than ingredients; they are memories of the past, hope for the future, and bring back the joys of family, fun, and love. This baked mac and cheese recipe from Chef Cheryl Johnson brings back memories of family, special dinners, Christmas, Thanksgiving, celebrations, holidays and the joy of eating together and enjoying time with loved ones. This dish is for celebrations!

You can customize this dish a lot based on the crowd you’re serving. If they like spices, don’t skimp on the seasoning. Paprika, black pepper, and even a pinch of red pepper flakes all go well with mac and cheese. If the mac and cheese seems too thick after baking, you can drizzle in a very small amount of milk while the dish is still piping hot and let it absorb before serving.

How Is Layered Baked Mac and Cheese Different?

Most modern recipes start with a roux, cooking butter and flour together before whisking in milk and cheese to make a smooth sauce. Layered, or custard-style, mac and cheese skips that step. The cheese and butter go straight onto the noodles, and the milk soaks in during baking, so the dish sets into sliceable layers with pockets of melted cheese and crisp, browned edges. It’s a traditional style beloved in many Southern and family kitchens, and is nearly impossible to ruin.

How Do You Make Baked Mac and Cheese?

Preheat the oven to 365°F. Boil a box of macaroni according to the package directions, then drain and rinse it well. Rinsing removes excess starch so the noodles stay separate.

Cut a stick of butter into 8 tablespoons using the markings on the wrapper. Spread one-third of the noodles in a large baking pan, season with salt and pepper, and dot with 3 tablespoons of butter. Cover the noodles completely with 2 cups of grated sharp cheddar.

Add the second layer of noodles, season, dot with butter, and top with 2 cups of mild cheddar. Add the final layer of noodles, season, dot with the remaining butter, and finish with the last 2 cups of sharp cheddar, making sure the cheese covers every noodle.

Slowly and evenly pour 3 cups of milk over the top. Bake for 60 minutes. If the top is browned but milk remains in the pan, keep baking for up to 30 minutes more.

Why Is My Baked Mac and Cheese Still Runny?

Don’t judge doneness by the top alone. The cheese can brown well before the milk in the center has been absorbed. Insert a knife into the middle of the dish; it’s done when the knife comes out clean and no liquid pools at the bottom. If it’s still wet, return it to the oven, tenting the top loosely with foil if it’s getting too dark. On the other hand, if the finished dish seems too thick or dry, drizzle a little milk over it while it’s still hot.

Tips for Success

Grate your own cheese. Pre-shredded cheese contains anti-caking agents that keep it from melting as smoothly.

Use a deep pan. A deep 9-by-13-inch baking dish or larger holds all three layers and the milk. Set it on a rimmed baking sheet to catch drips.

Add a little heat. Sprinkle each layer with paprika, extra black pepper, or a pinch of red pepper flakes for guests who like spice.

Let it rest. Resting the dish for 10 to 15 minutes after baking helps it set, so it cuts into neat squares.

Can I Make This Mac and Cheese Recipe Ahead of Time?

Assemble the layers up to a day ahead, cover, and refrigerate without the milk. Pour in the milk just before baking, and add 10 to 15 minutes to the bake time. Leftovers keep for up to four days; reheat portions with a splash of milk.

What Dietary Swaps Can You Make for This Recipe?

Gluten-free: Use gluten-free elbow macaroni and rinse it gently, as gluten-free pasta can be more delicate.

Dairy-free: Use plant-based cheddar shreds, plant-based butter, and unsweetened plain oat or soy milk.

What Can I Serve with Baked Mac and Cheese?

This mac and cheese pairs naturally with holiday ham, roast turkey, fried chicken, or barbecue, with collard greens or green beans alongside.

Find more favorites in our roundup of Mac and Cheese Recipes for a Cozy Kitchen, including Chef Jackie Page’s Homemade Mac and Cheese with Five Cheeses and the Go-To Cheddar Mac and Cheese. 

Fill out the holiday table with Jackie’s Green Bean Casserole and Sweet Potato Stacks.

Print
clock clock iconcutlery cutlery iconflag flag iconfolder folder iconinstagram instagram iconpinterest pinterest iconfacebook facebook iconprint print iconsquares squares iconheart heart iconheart solid heart solid icon
A white baking dish of golden layered baked mac and cheese beside a small plate with a serving.

Baked Mac and Cheese by Aunt Cheryl


  • Author: Cheryl Johnson
  • Total Time: 1 hour 30 minutes
  • Yield: Serves 10 or more 1x
  • Diet: Vegetarian

Description

Old-fashioned layered baked mac and cheese with butter, sharp and mild cheddar, and milk that bakes into a rich, sliceable casserole.


Ingredients

Scale
  • 1 box (16 oz) macaroni noodles
  • 4 cups sharp cheddar cheese, grated, divided
  • 2 cups mild cheddar cheese, grated
  • 1 stick (8 tbsp) butter
  • 3 cups milk
  • Salt and pepper, to taste


Instructions

  1. Preheat the oven to 365°F. Boil the macaroni according to package directions, then drain and rinse well.
  2. Spread one-third of the noodles in a deep baking pan. Season with salt and pepper and dot with 3 tbsp butter. Cover completely with 2 cups sharp cheddar.
  3. Add the second layer of noodles, season, dot with 3 tbsp butter, and top with 2 cups mild cheddar.
  4. Add the final layer of noodles, season, dot with the remaining 2 tbsp butter, and top with the remaining 2 cups sharp cheddar.
  5. Slowly and evenly pour the milk over the layers.
  6. Bake 60 minutes. If the top is browned but milk remains, bake up to 30 minutes more. It’s done when a knife in the center comes out clean and the milk is absorbed.

Notes

Gluten-free: Use gluten-free macaroni.

Dairy-free: Use plant-based cheese, butter, and milk.

Make ahead: Assemble up to 1 day ahead; add milk just before baking.

  • Prep Time: 20 minutes
  • Cook Time: 1 hour 10 minutes
  • Category: Side Dish
  • Method: Baking
  • Cuisine: American

Nutrition

  • Serving Size: 1/10 of the dish
  • Calories: 570
About the Recipe Author 

Cheryl Johnson, known to her family as Aunt Cheryl, is the owner of Aunt Cheryl’s Cafe.

About the Photographer 

Dave Bryce is TABLE Magazine‘s principal photographer. Known for images that explore depth and dimension through space and light, he is also a commercial and editorial food photographer who works closely with chefs and food stylists. See more of his work in TABLE Magazine.

Subscribe to TABLE Magazine’s print edition

- Advertisement -

SUBSCRIBE TO TABLE'S Email Newsletter

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Choose your region

We respect your privacy.

spot_img

Related Articles

Spruce and Hickory Turkey Brine With Stuffing Bread Pudding

Three-time James Beard Award semifinalist Kristin Butterworth of Cork & Crust shares the smoky spruce brine and custardy sage stuffing bread pudding behind her Thanksgiving turkey.

Thanksgiving Smoked Turkey Tamales

Chef Kevin Hermann brines and smokes a turkey breast, then folds it into fluffy masa with chile-rich salsa roja for a holiday tamale feast that feeds 12.

Leftover Turkey Vegetable Soup Ready in 30 Minutes

Fire-roasted tomatoes, carrot, celery, and homemade turkey stock turn Thanksgiving leftovers into a light, warming one-pot soup.